’This case highlights the importance of thorough investigation and the need to hold claimants accountable for fundamentally dishonest claims,’ says head
A motorist has cost himself over £100,000 after pursuing £1.2m in compensation from 1st Central in a fake injury claim.
The driver claimed to have suffered psychological trauma, dizziness, tinnitus and back pain following a low-speed collision on 6 August 2019.
While he was awarded £5,500 in damages, the case saw the claimant pursue compensation for alleged lifelong injuries.
However, inconsistencies were found in his account, with medical professionals, including 1st Central’s psychiatric expert, finding no evidence to support claims of ongoing debilitating injuries.
His return to full-time employment – and even a pay rise following the collision – also cast doubt on the legitimacy of his claims.
Court case
The case was taken to court by 1st Central and legal advisors to the insurance industry HF.
Read: Fraud attempts with deepfakes surge over last three years
Read: FCA bans broker for fraud that led to client entering liquidation
Explore more fraud-related content here, or discover other news stories here
The claimant continued insist that his injuries were the result of the accident, although his claim was deemed to be dishonest and opportunistic.
He is now responsible for 1st Central’s legal costs of over £100,000.
The judge said: “The claimant’s assertions regarding the severity and long-term impact of his injuries are not credible.
“His evidence was inconsistent and unreliable and it is clear to me that the claimant exaggerated and feigned his symptoms in pursuit of substantial financial compensation.”
Alex Wilkinson, head of the large loss counter fraud team at HF, added: “This case highlights the importance of thorough investigation and the need to hold claimants accountable for fundamentally dishonest claims.
“Our team worked closely with 1st Central to expose the inconsistencies and contradictions in the claimant’s story, ultimately ensuring that justice prevailed.”

His career began in 2019, when he joined a local north London newspaper after graduating from the University of Sheffield with a first-class honours degree in journalism.
He took up the position of deputy news editor at Insurance Times in March 2023, before being promoted to his current role in May 2024.View full Profile
No comments yet