Commercial lines: underwriting flexibility and expertise

 2011 ranking2010 ranking2011 average score2010 average score
Chubb113.964
ACE223.93.98
Fusion343.893.86
Hiscox373.893.74

Personal lines: underwriting flexibility

 2011 ranking2010 ranking2011 average score2010 average score
Plum Underwriting174.013.73
Oak Underwriting2243.98
Chubb313.984.1

Average scores where 1=very poor, 5=excellent